The circumstances of Dundee boy Luke Hutton’s death portrayed by the Procurator Fiscal and Sheriff Davidson are truly horrific.
Seven-year-old Luke died at the Olympia Centre two years ago.
The sheriff acknowledges that the £40,000 fine will hurt only council tax payers, but contends that it was, nonetheless, necessary, and that cannot be argued with. But it does beg the question, if the council taxpayer will be carrying the cost of this wholly avoidable tragedy, who will be carrying the responsibility?
The sheriff says the failings were systematic.
We have heard this kind of language before, very recently, in Dundee, and in relation to Brandon Muir. In that case, too, “system” failings were said to be the cause, but apparently no individual was responsible.
Are we to hear the same lame excuses coming from Dundee Leisure? Or will either someone accept responsibility for their negligence and resign, or failing that, will the most responsible individuals be identified and sacked? One or other of these options is the only possible outcome given the findings of the court case. — Dan D Mann.
Dressed up as innovation
As hard as I try, I cannot find one person who agrees with Dundee City Council’s plans to sideline the Christmas message in Dundee.
In my workplace, churchgoers and non-attendees alike despair at the thought of the overall Christmas meaning becoming a victim to PC politicking dressed up as innovation.
Aside from the lack of public consultation, the interesting point in all of this is that the matter reputedly received unanimous support among councillors. I find it hard to believe.
Was everyone asleep when this matter was debated and voted on, or was the wording such that no one noticed? — Observer, Dundee.
What has changed?
I can’t believe the decision to name festive celebrations Winter Light Night.
Also, why now do you rarely see Merry Christmas on Christmas cards — it’s always Season’s Greetings.
What has changed? I would like to see Christmas celebrated as the religious festival it is and always has been in Scotland.
For instance, I wouldn’t expect, or indeed, want, the Muslims in Dundee to change the name of Ramadan, just in case it offends the Christians of this city.
Surely everyone’s feelings should be considered? — Stephen Stewart, Orchard Court, Dundee.
Day and time not right
I have been reading about the carry- on about the Christmas lights being switched on. I am very offended. My family are Catholics and we feel we have the right to celebrate Christmas the way we usually do.
I also feel that the day and time is out of order. My little girl is three-years-old and is usually in bed at 7pm, so having the lights go on at 9pm is no good. I’m sure a lot of other parents feel the same. I personally think that 5pm/5.30pm was a good enough time on a Sunday, when people are not working. — Concerned, Ormiston Crescent.
Put Christ back into Christmas
It was with disbelief I read of Dundee City Council dropping the name Christmas Lights and substituting it with Winter Lights Night.
I suggest the council have a rethink and put Christ back into Christmas. — J. McLean, Dundee.
Change is a shame
The Christmas lights switch on is something all families with kids look forward to at this time of year.
To take this away from them and renaming it the Winter Light Night, is a shame. — D. Kean, Dundee.
Controversy where none exists
People objecting to the name change of the Christmas lights switch on have created a controversy where none exists.
It is absurd to suggest this decision means Christians in Dundee will be denied the right to celebrate Christmas as a religious festival. — Reader.
Latest Balmossie talks prompted by Fire Board
Regarding the letters in the Tele on the status of Balmossie Fire Station in Broughty Ferry.
Chief Fire Officer Steven Hunter did not put the proposal for redeployment of Balmossie fire-fighters in the Towards a Safer Tayside consultation paper, it was the decision of members of the Fire Board at a meeting on Monday, November 16.
Previous to that, at a poorly-attended Fire Board meeting on September 23, it was agreed that the issue would be included into the papers for members at the meeting in November.
This item was placed on the agenda by the convener and the vice-conveners.
There were no fire officers, senior or otherwise at that meeting only Board members and the clerk to the Board.
Towards a Safer Tayside is an organic document that changes every year to allow the Fire and Rescue to move forward to the benefit of all areas of Tayside and the people living there.
We are living through difficult economic times and all the three constituent councils will have hard decisions to make whilst preparing the budget for February. Departments in councils are being asked to make efficiency saving and the best use of their resources — why would Tayside Fire and Rescue be any different? — Christina Roberts, Vice-convener, Tayside Fire and Rescue.
Blame X Factor judges
People should not criticise t he X Factor contestants Jedward, who are clearly not exactly musical maestros.
They are just two kids making the most of an opportunity.
If anyone deserves to be castigated for their role in the affair, it’s the X Factor judges.
Louis Walsh selected them in his final three and Simon Cowell had a gilt-edged chance to vote them out, but chose not to.
Jedward may not be music to our ears, but they deserve credit for giving it a go, in the face of huge opposition. — X Factor Watcher.
Waiting to hear about census
I watched a man park his car in Abbotsford Place, Dundee.
He walked down Peddie Street, heading towards the Hawkhill/Perth Road area.
I find this most annoying as there were parking spaces further down Peddie Street.
A census about parking in this area happened about 18 months ago.
We still have heard nothing official regarding this, but we have heard that there is a high demand for spaces in this area of the city.
When the census form was filled out, everyone was under the impression that we were going to be able to park outside our own front door. — West End Resident.
Bonfire night
Does letter writer Damp Squib have any children, or did they as a child, not enjoy the annual bonfire night celebrations?
I think it would be cruel to deny our children the joy of bonfire night as the council displays are excellent and are enjoyed by adults and children alike.
Surely it is safer to have these organised displays and will, in the long term, save money on the fire brigade and ambulance call outs.
If these displays are cancelled, people, who don’t necessarily know what they are doing, might try to organise fireworks in their gardens.
We all know this can lead to terrible accidents. — Anon.
Mural request
I am the parent of a child who attends a respite facility for children with profound and complex disabilities.
The premises have a back garden which has been fenced in for the children to use.
The parents who support the Comfort Fund were wondering if anyone could paint a mural on the fence to make the area more colourful and eye-catching for the children.
If you are able to help, please contact me on 01241 854031. — Janette Shepherd.
Coffee morning
There will be a Christmas coffee morning in St Margaret’s Episcopal Church Hall, Ancrum Road, Lochee, tomorrow, from 10am until noon.
All the usual stalls. Tickets available at the door. — St Margaret’s Vestry.
THE ADDRESS for readers’ letters is - Readers’ Page, Evening Telegraph, 80 Kingsway East, Dundee DD4 8SL. They can also be placed in our post box at our offices in Albert Square, Dundee, emailed to us on letters@eveningtelegraph.co.uk or faxed on 01382 454590. We ask correspondents using a nom-de-plume or sending by e-mail to provide a name and address for reference purposes. The editor reserves the right to reject or edit any letter. Please keep letters as short as possible.*