| I have been reading the recent articles about Dundee Railway Station and don’t think the criticism is justified.
It’s just politicians looking to gain popularity by criticising ScotRail (and others).
Bearing in mind Dundee is a relatively small city, this station is rather good.
Apart from general maintenance I don’t think it needs a lot of money spent on it.
It’s not a new station we need, it’s a better train service.
In recent years I have travelled on trains in Scotland, England, France, Belgium and the Netherlands.
Our stations are just as good as in those countries.
However, trains in Belgium and Netherlands are cheap, plentiful and they run on time.
In Scotland the trains are expensive, unreliable, and it’s often difficult to get a seat on long journeys.
Instead of criticising Dundee station, Jim McGovern and other politicians should be trying to reopen the station at Errol, reopening lines to St Andrews, and getting more trains to stop at places like Carnoustie, Monifieth, Broughty Ferry and Invergowrie.
We should not be jealous of Edinburgh (where lots of money is being spent on the two main stations) as that’s our capital city and needs to be a showpiece. Edinburgh’s stations need to be as fine as those in other capital cities.
The best railway station I have seen (so far) is Brussels Gare du Midi which is out of this world.
It would be really something if any Scottish station could come close to matching that (pictures of Gare du Midi can be found on the Internet). — Kenneth Brannan.
|