| DRAWING THE Line asks why Dundee folk should pick up the bill for people living in the surrounding areas such as Monifieth etc.
What bill? Dundonians pay their local tax as do people in Angus and Fife. Each council then adds the money to its main revenue from the Scottish Executive to provide services. People in Angus and Fife do not cost the city anything.
When Dundee had control of areas such as Invergowrie etc were the services any better or, allowing for inflation, the local tax lower? Not that I can remember. The only effect was a reduction in services and an increase in local tax to the people of Angus and Perthshire.
When these areas left Dundee was there a cut back in services or did this cause a huge rise in council tax? Not that I can remember. All I can remember is Labour councillors in the city whining about not having enough money to spend.
They should have been looking at running a tighter ship. Where else in Britain today can a workforce be guaranteed a no redundancy policy from their employers?
Drawing The Line writes about people from Angus using facilities such as Discovery Point in Dundee as if this was a bad thing.
A city like Dundee is a regional centre and will always attract people from round about to work and for leisure. This is what happens to every city in the world and this in turn creates employment, creates businesses and consequently more revenue. It is why Edinburgh, Glasgow and Aberdeen are booming and why cities all over the world are expanding.
When Tesco built its huge store on the Kingsway it was not just looking for customers from Dundee. Likewise an efficiently-run council should be cashing in on places like Discovery Point, Verdant Works, Mills Observatory, Ice Arena, Olympia, etc. If it is not able to do this, the answer is not to give it power over an even greater area.
Also in the same letters page a reader said Dundee needs park and ride facilities but cannot have them because of “tight” boundaries and calls for an expansion of the city.
Again I ask, why? Edinburgh has park and ride facilities — and they are in Fife. There are plenty of places for such facilities on Dundee’s boundaries just a lack of vision or will.
Honestly, the solutions to all Dundee’s ills do not lie with expanding its boundaries against the wishes of others. If the city addresses the reasons why Dundonians are deserting and becomes well-run and gives value for money people will want to return to be part of it success.
As a council taxpayer living and working in Dundee, I hope our councillors stop trying to blame others for their own shortcomings and brainwashing their citizens into thinking all will be well if they had control over the surrounding areas. Somehow I doubt it. — Proud Dundonian. |