| Letters - 30 January 2006 |
| EU has brought peace |
|
|
| IT NEVER ceases to amaze me that some readers continue to place the blame for all of Britain’s problems with the European Union. |
| The EU is far from perfect, and many of its institutions and policies require reform, but the EU has done wonders for Europe as a whole.
For hundreds of years, Europe tore itself apart.
However, since 1945, none of the present member states of the EU has been at war with another. This is the longest period in European history without one EU member state attacking another.
People who continually lambast the EU should consider whether they want stability in Europe, of which Britain is a part, or whether they wish to return to the days of selfish national interests and war.
As far as I am concerned, sacrificing national sovereignty is a price worth paying for peace, prosperity and freedom.
Scotland and England were at war with one another, on and off, for centuries until economic and political union, which was painful for many at first, transformed both countries into one of the most powerful states in the world.
If the Auld Enemies can patch up their differences and pull together in the same direction, why can’t Europe? — Europhile.
|
| Ninewells staff should park free of charge |
|
|
|
| I WAS disgusted to read the recent report on the apparent intimidation tactics employed to collect parking fines at Ninewells Hospital in Dundee.
I live in Canada, but lived and worked in the city for many years.
I was treated at Ninewells for a serious health condition and was fortunate to recover fully. I cannot speak highly enough of the doctors and nurses.
I always had difficulty in understanding how a private business was somehow established out of an institution built out of taxpayers’ money.
Doctors, nurses and for that matter all employees who work in the hospital should be allowed a parking area at no charge. Without them how could this “business” operate?
There would appear to be no shortage of money to finance wars in Iraq and Afghanistan. — Joseph Lyall. |
| Give us a tax rebate |
|
|
|
| IN ADDITION to the never- ending roadworks around the Nethergate area, am I right in thinking that Dundee City Centre is a constant building site, with pavements dug up, resurfaced and then dug up again?
I think the city council should offer us a council tax rebate in the form of a disturbance payment.
The city centre building site does not enhance Dundonians’ quality of life. — Jim Hutchison, Dundee.
|
| Flawed legislation |
|
|
|
| IT WAS suggested by one correspondent that MPs voted against the 90-day Detention Bill because of opposition to Tony Blair.
I believe the vast majority of the MPs who opposed the Bill did so because they saw it as flawed legislation that wouldn’t make much of a difference against terrorism.
Anyone who listened to the comments made by these MPs, before, during and after the Commons debate, knows much of their criticism was constructive.
Had Tony Blair worked with the House of Commons — as his Home Secretary was prepared to do — then we would have had a much stronger Bill. — Political Watcher.
|
| Small world |
|
|
|
| A FRIEND at university in Dundee wrote to me, enclosing an article regarding the Blue Mountains houses, a part of Dundee’s history.
I was very surprised, as the Blue Mountains are a famous part of Hong Kong. They have inspired many works of art and decorate many homes throughout the world.
One of the most famous is a Chinese lady standing, with the Blue Mountains behind her. I understand that many homes in Dundee and Scotland have this painting.
Perhaps sailors from Dundee took the name of the Blue Mountains home with them? It really is a small world.
We recently celebrated our New Year and, as always, we end by singing Auld Lang Syne by Rabbie Burns, who is also very popular here. The children study his poetry and tomes at school.
I hope your Blue Mountains will flourish. — Maggie Wong, Hong Kong.
|
| More compassion |
|
|
|
| WITH FREE concessionary fares for OAPs starting on April 1, at a cost of £159m for 2006/2007, rising to £163m for 2007/2008, I hope those bus companies who receive the payments treat the elderly with more compassion than they have in the past. Will the new smart card be accepted as a return ticket? Will users be entitled to a seat, like other ticket holders? I sincerely hope so. Often in the past, pensioners have been told to go to the back of the queue until the fare-paying passengers have boarded. — Jack Stewart, Pensioners’ Forum, Perth.
|
| Need same attitude |
|
|
|
| I AM disgusted about sex offenders and murderers being allowed out for a week per month. This type of behaviour shows just what is wrong with this country. In Thailand two murderers are to be executed by lethal injection. It makes you wish we had people in power here who were willing to show the same attitude. — Angus Rourke, Downfield, Dundee.
|
| Light up the bridge |
|
|
|
| DUNDEE CITY Council should consider illuminating the Tay Rail Bridge at night, along the same lines as the Forth Rail Bridge.
It would look quite impressive and give Dundee a bit more of that “special” feel. — Duncan MacDonald, Gourdie Road, Dundee.
|
| Simple solution |
|
|
|
| JOHN MONTGOMERY says health service waiting times are extended because of people adopting poor lifestyles. A previous correspondent blamed waiting times on immigrants.
I would imagine that both of these have an additive effect. The solution to both is quite simple — make the indigenous population do the work that appears at present to be beneath their dignity for some reason or other.
In the old days this was the case, and benefit was stopped after three jobs were turned down.
Making people work has added value in assisting a healthy lifestyle by giving less time for eating and hence reducing obesity problems.
There might be an added bonus in that the courts will not have so many people up before them for fighting and general low-life behaviour as their excess energy will be channelled into the workplace. — Worker.
|
| Too lazy |
|
|
|
| THE REASON for so many immigrants working in Britain is that they will take jobs our own citizens are often too lazy to do, being quite happy doing nothing.
In most cases the immigrants are extremely hard-working and conscientious.
Until it doesn’t pay to be idle in this country, it seems we will need immigrant workers — a sad reflection on our own society. — Hard Worker.
|
| Leave our booze alone |
|
|
|
| IT IS only a small minority of people who abuse drink, so why should the rest of us have to suffer?
From the viewpoint of an MSP earning over £1000 a week, a can of lager at 40p may seem cheap, but it’s not to many of the 33,000 over-60s in Dundee.
Why deprive us of one of the pleasures that we have in life? When one compares the price of drink to that of water, it is water that is overpriced. — Menzieshill.
|
| Happy with cheap drink |
|
|
|
| I AM sick to death of these so called alcohol campaigners going on about off-licences and supermarkets selling “cheap” booze and blaming them for Scotland’s binge drinking culture. What a joke.
If they lived in the real world they would know that people who binge drink will do so, no matter the cost.
I, for one, am very happy to put some beer or a bottle of wine in my trolley without paying extortionate prices like I have to for council tax, house prices and petrol, to name but a few. — Happy Hoose Drinker. |
| No tolls basis for charging |
|
|
|
| WHILE T. McARTHUR makes a lot of valid points, I fail to see why tolls on the bridges are actually necessary.
The reasoning that these roads are hammered by motorists, necessitating high maintenance costs, is not a basis for toll charging.
If that is the basis, then a number of roads had better watch out — the Kingsway in Dundee is more heavily used than the bridge.
What is the Road Fund Licence for?
We are a two-car family paying more than £300 per annum for the privilege of being doubly taxed by the tolls (approx £13.60 per week).
The notion of dodging the bridge by going home/to work via a less direct route makes no economic sense (approx 40 miles per round trip extra) and is not environmentally sound. — Dave, Newport.
|
| Army bullying |
|
|
|
| I HAVE no time for George Galloway and his party politics. However, I cannot agree with all the correspondents in regard to the so-called bullying by Mr Galloway.
I wonder if any of the letter writers have ever been in the armed forces. There we have bullying of the first order by sergeants and sergeant-majors.
You have to put up with it whether you hate it or not.
To compare MP Galloway’s so-called bullying with the bullying in the armed forces would, indeed, be laughable. — Ron Smith, Dundee. |
| Clamp down now |
|
|
|
| I’M GLAD the Government is clamping down on the people who are not genuinely incapacitated. It’s a joke when you see some who use sticks walking around the supermarket with the stick over his or her arm, then hopping into a taxi when he or she comes out. Then there are the bad back stories that can’t be proved.
I know someone who has had hip and knee operations and is back at work, whereas many play on this as an excuse not to work. We should clamp down on doctors who give out sick lines willy-nilly. — Tax Payer.
|
| Work for pittance |
|
|
|
| IT WOULD appear “doctors” Hutton and Blair have the cure if you are disabled — take away your rights, entitlement to benefits and make you work for a pittance. The Government cannot be allowed to undermine the rights for the disabled.
While trying to cut Incapacity Benefit, politicians send off lots of cash abroad under the charity banner, but are prepared to create poverty here. — Disabled, Fife.
|
| THE ADDRESS for readers’ letters is - Readers’ Page, Evening Telegraph, 80 Kingsway East, Dundee DD4 8SL. They can also be placed in our post box at our offices in Albert Square, Dundee, emailed to us on letters@eveningtelegraph.co.uk or faxed on 01382 454590. We ask correspondents using a nom-de-plume or sending by e-mail to provide a name and address for reference purposes. The editor reserves the right to reject or edit any letter. Please keep letters as short as possible.* |
| email |
|