Today's News | Sport | Features | Email Contacts | Letters | The Tele | D C Thomson | Annuals | Subscriptions | Old Dundee

Headlines
Sport Stories
Get the Tele from...

Letters - 08 August 2005
Any more cruel?

Cruelty to fish? Trawlermen haul in their nets.

WHILE I deplore the behaviour of the Fife man, who cut the tail off a goldfish, as featured in your courts column on August 3, I question whether his action was any more cruel than those of fishermen and cooks the world over.
Anglers, by the nature of their sport, must subject the fish to having barbed hooks embedded in their mouths, and deep-sea fishermen catch thousands of fish at a time in their nets, dump them in the holds of their vessels and leave the creatures to suffocate.

Many chefs toss live lobsters and crabs into boiling water to cook them for the benefit of their clientele. — Concerned, Craigiebank.

Object strongly
AN ARTICLE in the Tele advised that objections can still be made with regard to the proposed wind turbines at Michelin in Dundee.

It also reminded us that Michelin already has planning permission for three smaller turbines.

This permission was granted while Michelin awaited results from an anemometer to demonstrate the feasibility of erecting these turbines.

It appears the results indicated there would not be sufficient wind to justify the smaller turbines, so Michelin is hoping to erect turbines that are 70 metres higher instead.

If erected, these are not going to provide cheap electricity to any part of Dundee apart from the tyre factory.

Michelin has meanwhile stated it will provide blinds for houses affected by “shadow flicker”.

So residents will live in black-out conditions, especially during summer and incur higher electricity bills.

Michelin will also pay for just one year’s subscription to satellite TV for residents whose TV reception is affected. The lifespan of a wind turbine is 25 years.

Your article also mentioned that a petition was circulating among the residents.

I have no knowledge of this, but have submitted an objection form (available from the Department of Planning and Transportation, Floor 15, Tayside House).

I exhort anyone who is concerned about the possibility of living in the shadow of these turbines to object strongly. — Mrs Stella Mousley, Hawick Drive, Dundee.

Should take up fight
I WAS raging after reading the two letters in Tele about a lack of help from the council for elderly people.

I will be amazed if none of our councillors does not take up the fight on their behalf.

These unfortunate people need suitable housing.

MPs and MSPs should also get involved. — Love Rules.

I AM 78 and, like your letter writer, am getting rather stiff and cannot cope with my small garden.

I too asked for help from the council and was charged £30 for weeding and some weedkiller.

I had no grass to cut. Two men came and it took 25 minutes to complete the job. — Auld and Sair II.

Getting everything free . . .
I HAVE worked since the age of 16 and paid my taxes.

On a recent visit to the chemist to collect and pay for a prescription, I saw a young, designer-clad lady with a child in a designer pram taken aside by the chemist to be given free drugs. No doubt she gets everything else free as well.

Where is the incentive for people to work hard when people like this get everything free because he or she is a drug user? — Annoyed Tax Payer.

Poor attitude
HAS ANY other Tele readers noticed the attitude displayed by some Big Issue sellers?

I frequently purchase the magazine and always give extra to the vendor. I will not, however, purchase from anyone who is rude, pushy and intimidating.

I was astounded to be on the receiving end of a volley of expletives having politely declined an offer to purchase from a vendor.

I appreciate these people have difficult lives, but the lack of manners and approach of some vendors spoils it for their fellow sellers. — Manners Please.

Second-raters
MOBILE PHONES, diesel exhaust fumes and electric power lines cause health damage as do smokers.

With 78% against an outright smoking ban, why do we need one? I say let’s ban politicians and give Scotland back freedom of choice.

The Scottish Parliament consists of second-raters. Thank goodness their powers are limited. — Frank Falconer.

Not MP
I REFER to your article headed “Broughty Ferry, Angus blunder” on August 3. I was not aware MSP Shona Robison had been elected to serve as an MP as she was labelled in your picture caption. The words pot, kettle and black come to mind. — Alan Young, Invergowrie Drive, Dundee.

THE ADDRESS for readers’ letters is - Readers’ Page, Evening Telegraph, 80 Kingsway East, Dundee DD4 8SL. They can also be placed in our post box at our offices in Albert Square, Dundee, emailed to us on letters@eveningtelegraph.co.uk or faxed on 01382 454590. We ask correspondents using a nom-de-plume or sending by e-mail to provide a name and address for reference purposes. The editor reserves the right to reject or edit any letter. Please keep letters as short as possible.*
email