| THE lore goes like this, writes Phil Weir — the Jean-Francois Richet-directed Assault On Precinct 13 (15, seen at Dunfermline Odeon) is a remake of John Carpenter’s 1976 cult classic of the same name.
Not that Carpenter’s movie wasn’t itself a bit of a steal — he’d borrowed heavily from the Howard Hawks western Rio Bravo (1959), which had John Wayne and a motley band of law-men babysitting a senior baddie in a jail, while black- hatted flunkies hurled themselves at the brickwork in a bid to liberate him.
Truth is, this set-up’s worn-out bones, in slightly different guises, have been trudging round and round the block since the Greeks tried to bust Helen out of Troy, 3000 years ago.
That said, the new Assault is an enjoyable action thriller, with its familiar plotting attracting only a few minus points.
This time, the walls under siege are in contemporary Detroit.
Late on a snowy Hogmanay, uniformed police sergeant Jake Roenick (Ethan Hawke) is overseeing the mothballing of his antiquated precinct house, which sits in an isolated industrial area of the city.
There’s only a few other cops left in the building. Chiefly old-school veteran Jasper (Brian Dennehy) and secretary Iris (Drea de Matteo).
Also visiting is Jake’s shrink, Alex (Maria Bello), because he’s no ordinary desk sarge. He was an undercover narcotics detective, but when an operation went down wrong, and two of his fellow cops got killed, Jake ended up with a lot of mental baggage and requested easier duties. Hence the scheduled therapy session, even though it is New Year’s Eve.
As the bells mark midnight, the assembled few get in the party spirit, but soon the arrival of a tall, dark stranger changes the mood.
Recently-arrested top gangster and cop killer Marion Bishop (Laurence Fishburne) and a few other low-grade crims are getting transported cross-city to the state penitentiary, but when a major blizzard hits Detroit and makes travel almost impossible, their prison bus is re-routed to Precinct 13 for an overnight stay.
The trouble is, the diversion has been engineered by dark forces and, in no time, the remote precinct house is under siege by masked men with the tiny garrison facing a storm of fire-power. Soon Jake is having to draw on old skills and dormant reserves to keep the enemy at bay and is forced to consider freeing and arming his prisoners if any of them are to survive until dawn.
Of the two Assault movies, Carpenter’s wins hands down. It shocks almost from the start (the shooting of a young girl at an ice cream van), it has a fantastic sense of escalating menace, and also nurtures an enigma at its heart — the besieging forces are the teeming and mostly anonymous members of a strange, multi-ethnic street gang, whose motive for attacking the precinct house with such ferocity is never made fully clear, and who end up fading away into the night as mysteriously as they arrive.
The identities of the new film’s assaulting forces are, relatively, more mundane, as are their motives.
And made in pre-mobile phone days, it was also easier to believe Carpenter’s precinct building could have been placed incommunicado by the attackers.
With the new film, the blizzard and a New Year shutdown just about do the trick of explaining away why the outpost’s predicament goes unnoticed, but still the script has to resort to some quasi-scientific nonsense to explain why cell phones don’t work and the cavalry can’t be called.
However, Precinct The Younger does have the edge on its no-name-cast predecessor, in terms of actors. Hawke is always highly watchable and Fishburne brings the same powerful presence to the feast as he did to the Matrix movies. The minor league players, too, are top-notch with the too-seldom-seen-these-days Dennehy outstanding and Gabriel Byrne and John Leguizamo adding clout in other roles.
The location is also atmospherically claustrophobic and the action frequent and explosive.
But can you answer me one burning question? Why do American cops of Irish descent all still have strong Irish accents, even though their great, great, great, great granddaddies emigrated from the Emerald Isle in 1846 and have been in the States and steeped in Yankee talk ever since? That’s the enigma this film nurtures at its heart.
VERDICT: An assault on a classic, but still plenty gripping.
Three stars |