| THE CHIEF of the Defence Staff is quite right to say what he did about elements of the media endangering The Black Watch.
Although local Press and similar media have been supportive, all is not well.
People who were there have said they were convinced Press, plus parliamentary interest and debate, made The Watch a “celebrity target”
To support General Walker, on the day the 1BW Battle Group moved north from Basra, the BBC Six O’Clock News asked their reporter on the scene what was going on.
“You realise there are things I can’t tell you,” he replied, and delivered some very circumspect generalities.
By contrast, ITN’s news dealt with the subject in depth, with a chirpy studio-bound presenter helpfully indicating on a map just where our lads would bivouac for the night, before setting off for Camp Dogwood in the morning.
It hardly takes a genius to work out that an insurgent sympathiser would need only seconds to phone his chums to expect a bunch of guys with red hackles to pass by in the forenoon. With friends like these, who needs enemies?
By and large, the national media’s handling of the whole Iraq deployment shows that they do not know what they are talking about.
Nearly every picture caption from Iraq contains an error of fact, from types of equipment to ranks and appointments; and their would-be “cool” use of military terminology, most of which they get wrong.
Unless, of course, it’s all a cunning plan to confuse the enemy, in which case they’ve done a pretty good job of confusing the whole issue. — A. Maclean, Maryfield, Dundee.
MY SON, a serving soldier, was in Iraq. I don’t believe it was the media which was responsible for the deaths of five Black Watch soldiers, despite the general’s claim. I blame Tony Blair and Geoff Hoon. They sent the men to Camp Dogwood.
My thoughts are with the families.
The media took letters to the men from their families when they went to Iraq. If it hadn’t been for the news, we wouldn’t have known anything or seen our sons on TV.
The Ministry of Defence never got in touch with the families. — Proud Soldier’s Mother.
|