| UNTIL RECENTLY I believed time travel to be impossible. However, someone in Dundee has managed to transport themselves back to the Victorian age before returning to the present day armed with the values and the ideals of the time.
This is the only explanation I can come up with to explain the nonsense sent to the Tele letters page under the pseudonym Law Abider.
To describe nursing as “women’s work” is massively insulting to all nurses, irrespective of their gender.
In the past ten years I have been employed in all manner of jobs including such traditionally masculine work as shot blasting, construction and bar managing and I have never in any of these jobs broken more sweat than I have over the past two-and-a-half years while I have been a student nurse at Dundee University.
The astronomic number of nurses forced into retirement each year due to injuries such as back problems resulting from the manual handling of both patients and heavy equipment is testament to the physical labour nurses undertake on a daily basis.
Perhaps if Law Abider was engaged in such a physically and mentally demanding career he would be too exhausted at the end of a shift to write such ill-informed drivel. — Third-Year Student Nurse.
AS A male nurse of many years experience I am furious at Law Abider. How dare he insinuate that healthy young men are “driven” to do women’s work.
Nursing is a profession for both sexes, as is being a doctor. Would LA refuse treatment from a female doctor?
As for breaking sweat, we nurses break sweat every day we are on duty.
It also does not help being verbally and physically abused by our clients. I wouldn’t give this man 10 minutes in a general or psychiatric hospital. He would not be able to hack it.
Before nursing I worked for a tyre company and had to fill an articulated lorry with car, bus, lorry and earthmovers’ tyres by hand.
So I have broken sweat in both jobs. Law Abider should be ashamed of himself. — Steven Davidson, Enrolled Nurse, Liff Hospital.
I REPLY to Law Abider’s letter. If men choose this career, then they have every right to work as nurses. In fact, the profession’s roots lie within a male environment, as it was monks who used to care for the sick and dying, even before nursing became “women’s work”.
These men do a fantastic job and are generally well-received and respected amongst patients and colleagues alike.
The NHS already faces a recruitment crisis and if men are willing to join our ranks, then we are happy to have them.
As for their duty to get the economy back on track, then what about the thousands of men (and women) who choose not to work but to live on government benefits? (I appreciate there are people with valid reasons for being unable to work).
Nurses work hard for a meagre wage. We work long, unsociable hours and demanding shifts trying to balance ever-decreasing resources and often bearing the brunt (as the “public face of the NHS”) when things don’t always go as people would like.
We are often understaffed and overworked, and breaking a sweat is the least of our worries. — Tired Nurse, Dundee.
I WOULD defy Law Abider to work on any shift in hospital. Break sweat, he comments. I doubt if he knows the meaning of the phrase.
Is he on his feet 12 hours a day? Nurses frequently do without tea and lunch breaks because of staffing and patient requirements.
I doubt he has been in a hospital environment, otherwise he wouldn't make such stupid comments. — Nurse’s Partner.
DOES LAW Abider think in this day and age nursing is a job only for women? My wife has been unwell for almost three years, and the staff at Ward 22, Ninewells Hospital, have been superb.
This includes the male nurses and the senior charge nurse, Sean. The male and female staff do a great job. I was a paratrooper for ten years, and all our medics were male.
Hopefully Law Abider doesn’t fall ill in the near future as he may have to be treated by male nurses who don’t “break sweat” like the rest of us. — Ripcord.
|